Heat Maps and Choropleths: Density and Regional Values Compared

heat map vs choropleth map

If you’re weighing a heat map vs choropleth map, start with your data: many scattered points suit a heat map, while values already tied to areas such as districts suit a choropleth. The sections below show how to tell.

For the wider picture of mapping methods, read the guide to geospatial data visualization.

Item Value
Heat map input Point features, best when many points overlap
Heat map density method Kernel density
Heat map rendering methods Constant and Dynamic
Choropleth data treatment Classified into ranges, one color per range
Practical limit of distinguishable colors About seven colors

These figures come from the ArcGIS Pro documentation on heat map symbology and graduated colors. Software documentation changes between releases, so check the sources before you rely on them.

What each map actually shows

A heat map turns point locations into a smooth surface. In ArcGIS Pro, heat map symbology draws point features as a dynamic, representative surface of relative density. Instead of reading a crowd of overlapping dots, you see where events cluster.

A choropleth map colors whole areas. Data is classified into ranges that are each assigned a different color from a color scheme, and maps that vary in color this way are usually called choropleth maps. Every polygon, such as a district, receives a single color across its entire area.

The core difference is where the pattern comes from. A heat map estimates a continuous surface from points and ignores boundaries, while a choropleth reports a value that already belongs to a boundary.

How a heat map gets its colors

The surface comes from a statistical calculation, not from the points themselves. The density is calculated using the kernel density method, the same algorithm used by the Kernel Density geoprocessing tool. The tool’s documentation adds that conceptually, a smoothly curved surface is fitted over each point.

Colors then run along a ramp. Ideally, the color scheme is a smoothly varying set of colors, ranging from cool (sparse density of points) to hot (high density of points).

Two settings shape what you see:

heat map vs choropleth map Street grid
Long straight roads divide a sprawling city into rectangular blocks.

Constant or dynamic: when heat map colors mislead

A heat map’s colors are relative, which catches many readers out. The density definition, and therefore the color values, change as you zoom in and out when the rendering is dynamic.

The two rendering methods serve different jobs:

If two heat maps will sit side by side, make sure both use the same density definition. Otherwise the “hottest” color on each may mean something different.

How a choropleth gets its colors

Choropleth colors come from classes you choose. Typically, you choose a continuous color scheme to apply different shades of the same color so that lighter shades match lower data values and darker shades match higher data values. Because each class is a range, the classification method changes the story the map tells.

Class count matters too. The same documentation notes that a range of seven colors is the approximate upper limit of colors that can be clearly distinguished on a map. It also advises you to avoid too many classes, especially with light colors.

Raw counts per area often mirror how big or populous each area is. The documentation’s answer is normalization: choose percentage of total to divide the data value to create ratios, or choose log to symbolize on the logarithm of each value. For the full build, see this walkthrough of how to make a choropleth map.

When values swing around a meaningful midpoint, a diverging scheme helps. The same page shows a choropleth map that uses a diverging color scheme to show net migrant population growth or loss by district in the Czech Republic.

Which one should you choose?

Match the map to the shape of your data, not to which looks more striking:

Whichever you pick, color ramps, legends and labels decide whether readers trust the result. The guidance on cartographic design principles applies to both map types.

Mistakes that make either map misleading

  1. Comparing dynamic heat maps. Each view rescales its colors, so a hot spot in one extent may be mild in another.
  2. Letting outliers flatten the ramp. ArcGIS Pro lets you slide the stop values, which is an effective approach when there are a few extreme outlier values that otherwise wash out the symbology.
  3. Shading raw totals by area. Large or populous regions look important simply because they hold more. Normalize first.
  4. Overloading the legend. Too many classes blur together, especially in pale shades.
  5. Treating a smooth surface as exact. The radius you pick shapes the picture, so state it where readers can see it.

Frequently asked questions

Can I make a heat map from polygon data?

Show answer

ArcGIS Pro describes heat map symbology as a way to draw point features, per its heat map documentation. Values that belong to polygons are better served by a choropleth.

Is graduated colors the same thing as a choropleth?

Show answer

In practice, yes. The graduated colors page says maps built this way are usually called choropleth maps.

Why does my heat map change color when I zoom?

Show answer

You are probably using the Dynamic method, which rebuilds the color ramp for whatever features are on screen. Switch to Constant when you need stable colors, as the heat map documentation describes.

How many classes should a choropleth have?

Show answer

Keep the legend short. Roughly seven shades is where the eye stops telling them apart, according to the graduated colors documentation, so fewer is often safer.