Build a Choropleth Map with Appropriate Rates and Class Breaks

how to make a choropleth map

Wondering how to make a choropleth map that doesn’t mislead? Shade areas by a rate or ratio, not raw counts, then pick class breaks that suit your data. Normalize first, classify second, and the pattern becomes readable.

This guide belongs to the wider topic of geospatial data visualization, where choropleths sit beside other ways of showing place-based data.

Item Value
Default symbol type for rate/ratio fields in ArcGIS Insights Counts and amounts (Color)
Default symbol type for number fields in ArcGIS Insights Counts and amounts (Size)
Default classification method in ArcGIS Insights Natural breaks
Default number of bins in ArcGIS Insights 5 bins
Typical number of breaks in an ArcGIS Pro color coded layer 3 to 7 breaks

These defaults come from the ArcGIS Insights map layer options page and the ArcGIS Pro color coded layer page. Software settings can change, so check the source before you rely on the figures.

What a choropleth map actually shows

A choropleth map shades areas, such as counties or police districts, according to a value. ArcGIS Insights describes it as graduated color applied to normalized data, drawn as shaded points, lines, or areas (ArcGIS Insights).

The question it answers best is how rates or percentages compare from one place to the next. The same documentation gives the example of an analyst mapping unemployment rates across police districts and comparing them to crime rates (ArcGIS Insights).

If you are still deciding which map style fits your data, the guide to types of thematic maps sets the options side by side.

Why raw counts mislead on a choropleth

Graduated color invites a visual trap: larger areas draw the eye, especially when they are dark. The ArcGIS Insights documentation warns that this effect appears when features differ in size or population (ArcGIS Insights).

Its restaurant example makes the point. On a map of total restaurants, big counties with many restaurants, such as Long Island and the Boston area, stand out even over smaller New York City counties that share the same color (ArcGIS Insights). The per capita version of that map is the correct choropleth, according to the same page.

The fix is to style by averages, proportions, rates, or ratios rather than counts or totals (ArcGIS Insights). If totals are what you want to show, a graduated symbol map suits them better, per the same documentation.

How to make a choropleth map step by step

The steps below follow ArcGIS Insights. Menu names differ between tools, so treat the order of operations as the part to keep.

  1. Gather a table with one row per area and a boundary layer that matches it, such as counties or districts.
  2. Pick a rate, ratio, or proportion field. Insights creates a choropleth automatically when you map a rate/ratio field (ArcGIS Insights).
  3. If you only have a total, such as number of crimes, map it first and then switch the symbol type from the size option to the color option (ArcGIS Insights).
  4. Set the Divide by field to a base such as total population so the total becomes a proportion (ArcGIS Insights).
  5. Choose a classification method and a number of classes, as described in the next two sections.
  6. Choose a color palette, then read the legend as a stranger would before you share the map.

The process in step four is called normalization. You take one number, such as total crimes, and divide it by another, such as total population, to create a proportional value (ArcGIS Insights).

Which class breaks should you choose?

Classification groups numeric values into ranges, and each range gets one shade. The right method depends on your data and on what you want the map to say (ArcGIS Insights).

how to make a choropleth map Paper map
An aged paper map lies beneath a compass and round metallic objects.

These are the main methods you will meet in ArcGIS tools:

  • Natural breaks places boundaries where the data show relatively big jumps, which suits a single dataset (ArcGIS Pro). Insights uses it automatically for numeric data (ArcGIS Insights).
  • Equal interval splits the value range into equal-sized subranges (ArcGIS Insights). It works best on familiar ranges such as percentages and temperature, and a field running from 0 to 300 split into three classes gives 0-100, 101-200, and 201-300 (ArcGIS Pro).
  • Quantile puts an equal number of features in each class, but the map can mislead because similar values may land in different classes (ArcGIS Pro). Adding more classes reduces that distortion, per the same page.
  • Standard deviation shows how far each feature sits from the mean (ArcGIS Insights).
  • Unclassed displays numeric data on a continuous scale rather than in discrete classes (ArcGIS Insights).
  • Manual lets you set custom breaks, for example round numbers (ArcGIS Insights).

A practical habit is to try two or three methods on the same field. Keep the one whose shades match how the values are really spread, not the one that produces the most dramatic map.

How many classes and which colors?

Insights starts with 5 bins for natural breaks, equal interval, and quantile (ArcGIS Insights). The ArcGIS Pro color coded layer help says the number of breaks typically ranges from 3 to 7 breaks (ArcGIS Pro).

Color ramps come in two families. A sequential ramp runs from light to dark in a single color, while a diverging ramp uses two colors with dark shades at both extremes (ArcGIS Insights).

Diverging ramps pair well with standard deviation classes, because the neutral middle sits at the mean (ArcGIS Insights). ArcGIS Online also lets you filter ramp options by category, such as colorblind friendly, and flip the ramp direction (ArcGIS Online).

Checks before you publish

Run through this short list before the map leaves your desk:

  • Confirm the shaded field is a rate, ratio, or proportion, not a total.
  • When two maps must be compared, apply the same bins to both so differences are not artifacts of classification (ArcGIS Insights).
  • Read the legend aloud: could someone tell what each shade means without help?
  • Look for one oversized area that dominates the picture despite normalized data.

If your source data are individual points rather than areas, the comparison in heat map vs choropleth map explains when each approach fits.

Frequently asked questions

Can you make a choropleth map from raw totals?

Show answer

Not reliably. Divide the total by a base such as population to get a proportional value, or switch to a graduated symbol map if the totals themselves are the story (ArcGIS Insights).

Why does my map change when I switch classification methods?

Show answer

Each method sets its boundaries by a different rule, so the same data can produce a different pattern of shades. Test a few and keep the one that represents your values honestly.

How do I make two choropleth maps comparable?

Show answer

Give both maps identical custom breaks. Natural breaks are tuned to the data in front of them, so two maps classified that way cannot be read side by side (ArcGIS Insights).

Do I need a diverging palette?

Show answer

Usually no. A single-color ramp is enough for most rate maps; reach for two colors only when departures above and below a meaningful middle value matter.